The Tangled Bank
It is interesting to contemplate a tangled bank, clothed with many plants of many kinds, with birds singing on the bushes, with various insects flitting about, and with worms crawling through the damp earth, and to reflect that these elaborately constructed forms, so different from each other, and dependent upon each other in so complex a manner, have all been produced by laws acting around us.
The Tangled Bank is many things. It is a famous metaphor used by Charles Darwin in the passage quoted above. It is the blog carnival that you are reading right now. And it is a very good description of modern science.
Once upon a time, science was considered to be a largely academic endeavor. Academic scientists, like academic historians, English professors, and other such university types, were largely secure in their ivory tower. Commercial, political, and other "applied" aspects of science were frowned upon. This is still sometimes the case, of course, but the distinctions have become more and more blurred. Science, now more than ever, is part of modern life, and life is more connected to science. The difference is no longer clear. As in the picture of the tangled bank above, it's not really possible to pick a point where pure science ends and applied begins.
Now that my little introductory sermon is done, on to the links:
Before we get to the posts discussing scientific discoveries, we have a some reminders that science is a field that is, above all else, a human occupation. And we humans are, of course, what we are.
Ms. PhD of YoungFemaleScientist
shows us that the practice of science is sometimes different from the ideals
, and that people don't always live up to their responsibilities. GrrlScientist
has a post that compliments this one rather nicely, discussing some of the university politics
that interfere with some of those minor things that the schools do - the little things, like educating students.
From Dr. Mom
, we have a nice article about the giant squid, and how it relates to the loss of prestige that scientists have experienced in American culture
. (This blog was new to me, and may be new to you as well. If it is, take some time to look through some of the other posts, too. There's a series in progress on how to write a scientific paper that's shaping up to be particularly good.)
On a more somber note, Orac
provides us with a needed reminder that the history of the euthanasia and eugenics movements
include far more than just the history of Nazi Germany. Sometimes crimes against humanity start at home.
This week, we also have a pair of posts
on the love-hate relationship between economics and the environment. The perspectives the two take are somewhat different from each other, and I'm not sure whether or not I agree with either of them, but it is definitely worth remembering that the relationship between humans and our environment is complex, and that when we look at the effects that we have on the environment we cannot ignore the effects that the environment has on the way we live.
Shifting from the practice of science to actual scientific news, we'll start with the realm of the very large, out at galactic scales. In one of the very few "pure" science posts for this edition, The Bad Astronomy Blog
, gives us a nice look at the Andromeda galaxy
using two different types of imaging: visible light and infrared.
At the moment, a hurricane with a name that starts with "W" is roaming the Atlantic. This storm is getting some attention, since the list of storm names ends with "W". The next tropical storm in the Atlantic (if there is one) will receive the highly original name of "Alpha". The sheer number of storms this year, coupled with the strength of Katrina and Rita, has lead to a great deal of discussion about the relationship between hurricanes and global warming. If this type of thing interests you, you might want to take a look at the Oxford University Press Blog, which gives us a short interview with author Kerry Emanuel on Hurricanes and Global Warming
Moving on, Dr. Freeride
reminds us that this is National Chemistry Week
. On the lines of chemistry, the applications of chemistry, and the increasingly blurry distinction between pure and applied sciences, we get a reminder from In the Pipeline
that Big Pharma does Real Science
, too. (Even if the criteria for success are slightly different than they are for academics.) There's also an interesting article on biochemistry and trust
I don't know exactly how to classify the next entry. It might be physics, it might be chemistry, it might be an environmental post - it's a mini-tangled bank all by itself in some ways. Sometimes the simple solutions are the best solutions, and sometimes you get really lucky and the simple solution to one problem turns out to solve a whole bunch of other things, too. Political Calculations
blogs about some of the unexpected benefits that may come from a rubberized pavement
designed to reduce noise.
In the field of the cognitive sciences, Dave Munger has an article over at Cognitive Daily
about how humans learn the deceptively simple process of pattern recognition
We've got a few field-biology submissions this week. 10000 Birds
reports on a recently published article on Barn Swallow mating
. The report demonstrates something that many of us already suspected - the odds of successful monogamy increase if you put effort into continuing to look good even after the honeymoon.
One of the nicer things about fieldwork is that you can often see more interesting (or at least photogenic) things in the field than you do in the lab. Over at Henry's Webiocosm Blog
, there's a picture that reminds us that life has a way of turning up and hanging on
even in the most unexpected places. On a more seasonal note, there's a nice picture of variability in leaf colors
over at the Botany Picture of the Day
website. The post that it's attached to is worth reading, too.
Jennifer Forman Orth, of The Invasive Species Weblog
, comments on a recent case
that appears to demonstrate that the financial penalties that may occur if you get caught after causing problems by introducing a pest to an area probably don't outweigh the benefits to doing it in the first place. The issue of invasive species is one that I've been thinking about a lot lately, since the effects of a new invasive out here in paradise
are becoming more noticeable as time goes on. The post of my own that I link to is an old one, but if you check back in a day or so there will be a large, but not happy, update to the story.
We also have a number of posts about genetics this week. Some of them are more reality-based than others, but all are interesting. EvolGen
decided to address a cartoon character's question about whether or not a somewhat atypical set of relationships constitutes incest
. The scenario might seem a bit silly, but it takes a nice look at the mechanics involved in figuring out genetic risks. Keats' Telescope
brings us an article on the amount of "free" DNA that can be found in ocean sediments
. This research has some interesting implications, particularly when it comes to the utility and validity of genomics work with "environmental" samples
discusses the vast diversity that seems to exist within each species of bacteria
. It's interesting stuff. We tend to forget that something in excess of 99.99% of all life that has ever lived on this planet, by any measure you choose to use, is some sort of bacteria. Their genetics are very different from the life we usually look at, and we are only just beginning to fully grasp the depth of the evolutionary and medical implications that this raises. PZ Myers
reminds us that there can be more to the way that DNA works than just the order of As, Ts, Cs, and Gs with an article on Tourette's Syndrome
There's also a few posts worth looking at (here
) that discuss an article in Science
about intellectual property rights and the human genome. Apparently, lots of genes have been patented so far, some of them more than once. Allowing people ot patent chunks of human DNA sequence has its good and bad points, I guess, but it does feel a bit creepy sometimes. As long as they don't start requiring us to get tattooed with the patent numbers, I guess I can live with it.
That pretty much concludes the posts that were submitted to me for this edition of Tangled Bank. There do, however, seem to be a couple of big things missing. I received only one submission
that was directly related to creationism this time. That's particularly strange, since there is currently a major lawsuit underway in federal court related to a Dover, Pennsylvania school board policy. Anyone interested in the trial can find pretty much all the information that they want over at The Panda's Thumb
. There's also a good series of posts available there on bird flu, which is the other big gap in this week's posts.
That wraps it up for this one, folks. It's been a pleasure hosting this, and I hope to do it again someday.
The next edition will be posted on November 2, at The Examining Room of Dr. Charles
. Submissions can be sent to Dr. Charles
, to PZ Myers
, or to email@example.com